
Problem Baker
Unclaimed listingStaten Island · Bakery · 870 Castleton Ave
Problem Baker is a cookie and coffee company "99 PROBLEMS. A COOKIE AIN'T ONE." Cookies, coffee, and culture are baked in New York and shipped nationwide. The website offers boxes of 6, 12, or 24 cookies, a build-your-box option, and local ordering in New York.
Problem Baker began in a California kitchen and made its way to New York, where a home kitchen became a bakery. The Staten Island shop is open, and Park Slope is coming soon. Catering and events include cookie drops, a staffed Problem Baker cart, and the PB Bar with signature lattes, refreshers, and flavored milks.
From problembaker.com, checked October 25, 2026.
Hours
Hours not listed yet. Ask the assistant, or give them a call.
From their website
- cookies
- coffee
- signature lattes
- refreshers
- flavored milks
From problembaker.com, checked October 25, 2026. Menus and prices change, so ask or call to be sure.
Quickest way to an answer
Ask Problem Baker
Ask about anything on this page
Or ask something it doesn’t cover. It will say so.
Rather ask them yourself?
Not claimed by the owner
Nobody from Problem Baker has claimed this page. Answers are written by AI from public information, not by the business.
Unclaimed listing
Work at Problem Baker? Take over this page
Claim the listing and the answers here come from you, in your words, with your hours.
- Fix the hours and the menu
- Answer in your own voice
- See what people ask
Free. Takes about five minutes.
Quick answers
About Problem Baker
What is Problem Baker?
Problem Baker is a cookie and coffee company "99 PROBLEMS. A COOKIE AIN'T ONE." Cookies, coffee, and culture are baked in New York and shipped nationwide. Source: problembaker.com, checked October 25, 2026.
Where is Problem Baker?
Problem Baker is at 870 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310.
What is Problem Baker's phone number?
Call Problem Baker on (929) 909-3779.
What does Problem Baker serve?
Dishes on Problem Baker's website include cookies, coffee, signature lattes, refreshers and flavored milks. Menus and prices change, so check before you go. Source: problembaker.com, checked October 25, 2026.
Can I order from Problem Baker for delivery or takeout?
Problem Baker's website offers delivery. Source: problembaker.com, checked October 25, 2026.
What else does Problem Baker offer?
Problem Baker's website also mentions catering. Source: problembaker.com, checked October 25, 2026.
Reviews here
What people said on askpeppi
No reviews here yet. Be the first.
Been here? Log in to write a review. A person reads every review before it goes up.
Nearby
More places around Staten Island
Discover
For business
Get the local dispatch
New businesses and new tricks, when there's news.